251
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #113,278 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★★★☆
Proportions in the images are so very wrong (so far)
I am in LOVE with this book. It’s become my night time reading (heads up, it’s very heavy). It’s printed on superb paper and the imagaes are amazing.
I just tried the Macarons. I got all my ingredients ready as well as all the machinery, pots, piping bags etc. Very quickly I came to realize that this recipe must have been halved or quarterd (at least) from a commercial amount because there was no way that my stand up mixer would be able to whip up 3 Tbls of egg whites as the recipe called for... The whipping blade didn’t even touch them at the bottom of the bowl!
The recipe also asks for another 3 Tbls of egg whites, to be separately mixed with an immersion blender and the food coloring. Again, the blades of the immersion blender didn’t even touch the egg whites, and I had them in a tight measuring cup to be able to blend them. Yet.... if you look at the images that accompany the instructions (see attached image), the book shows as if the amount is so much that the rounded part of the blender practically get’s covered... all with one and half egg whites! This is physically imposible.
Same happened with melting 1/2 a cup of sugar with 2 Tbls of water to reach 245 degrees aprox. How to put your candy thermometer into that itty bitty amount, even if you use your smallest pot? It’s almost imposible without touching the bottom of the pot.
I wound up scrambling an trying to improvise... needless to say the result was so far from what macarons are supposed to look like. BUT... if I may say so, I had never eaten such yummy tasting ones! I can not show you my end result... it’s too embarrassing...
Oh... one more thing. The instructions after you have everything ready to assemble the macarons is quite deficient (I was aiming for chocolate macarons). They say to pipe the ganache on to the bottom of one macaron shell. But they also asked you to put that ganache in the fridge at least an hour ahead of time. Now, you are going to assemble them and the ganache is waaaay to hard to pipe! And there is no explanation as to how to pipe this hard ganache or why they have you place it in the fridge to begin with.
I believe that at least this particular recipe was not tried out with the listed amounts on their ingredient list. So some may ask why 4 stars? Because I have learned so very much from this book. Because it is a beautiful book. Because I’m not giving up on it. Not quite yet! If I find other issues with the book I will update my review. For now... read the recipe thoroughly and keep in mind this issue.
July 2018 · Books · verified purchase