Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

**THIRD UPDATE: I will finally admit that I'm obsessed with the shirt. This is the third that I've gotten and I love it. I decided to get a size small because I wanted to wear it with jeans and not have it quite so long and I kind a wish I would've gotten a small with the other two that I bought. The black one is similar to the gray, not quite as soft as the blue but it's comfortable and looks really cute with leggings or jeans. The only downsides to them is the sleeve length is a little shorter than I like, hitting right at the wrist when my arms are down, and the puffiness at the hips that makes me look a little bigger there than I am. I'm 5 foot 6 inches and about 125 lbs (I was around 130 when I ordered the last two, but I still think I should have gotten a small). **UPDATE: I bought the gray one because, despite the frump factor, the blue one is seriously the coziest shirt I've ever owned. It's the first thing I want to grab when I go to my closet. Like the kind of shirt you'd want to wear on a 12 hour flight kind of cozy. The gray one feels totally different, it's almost scratchy, even with a tank top under it and not quite as stretchy (the blue bounces back and doesn't stay stretched, btw). Maybe it's the dye, I don't know. I feel like it looks a little different, too, but you can be the judge of that - I posted pics of both. I bought a medium, I debated getting a small but then chickened out and bought the medium. I should have gotten the small. They're both super cute under light jackets. If you're not full in the hips, this is the perfect shape for you because it definitely adds a little something there. I'll probably keep it but for the time being I'm taking it off and putting the blue one back on. **Original review: Iwant to love this shirt but I'm not sure how I feel about it yet. The quality is good, it's really soft and the material doesn't look cheap. It's not super thick which is also nice, it's like a thick t shirt material. It seems to ride up above the band when I move and I feel like it makes me look frumpy unless my hands are in the pockets. It also makes my fluff more visible when it's not pulled away from my skin. I bought this because I thought the buttons on the neck made it look more interesting but I can't figure out how to make more of the buttons visible without it looking weird. It's probably why the model always has the neck pulled up with her hand. I'm 5ft 6in and 130 pounds and most of my extra weight is in my hips and thighs. I bought a medium but I think I could have gone with a small and been fine.