Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

In a thrilling emulation of Jan Vermeer's artistic style, Tracy Chevalier uses scenes drawn from everyday life and painstaking attention to detail to tell the story of Griet, a 16-year-old girl who is required by her family's misfortunes to become a maid in the Vermeer household. I devoured the book the first time through, then read it again to savor the starkly beautiful language and the highly sensual account of 17th century life in a busy Dutch household. On both forays, I drank in the vivid descriptions of Vermeer's paintings and his creative process, from the positioning of his models to the grinding of bone and lead, massicot, madder and ochre, to make his pigments. To those who complained that nothing happened or that the book was predictable, let me say, this was never meant to be a suspense story in the conventional sense. That an event could be foreseen doesn't render it improperly drawn. The magnetism of this tale is not its ability to surprise us with plot twists but to show the complex and fascinating interplay among people of different stations and sensibilities. Chevalier demonstrates her considerable skill in presenting Griet to be at the same time naive and intelligent, hemmed in by her lack of status and strong of spirit. Her resigned frustration over the many slights and unfair situations she must deal with strikes me as the only sensible option for one who must continue in employment for the sake of those she supports. Though I can't imagine Griet describing herself as anything but ordinary, her attention to detail--as keen in its own way as Vermeer's--and her understanding of the personalities and motives of those around her show her to be a remarkable young woman. The other main characters--sometimes as bound by their elevation as Griet is by her lack of it--behave with annoying reality. Maria Thins, Vermeer's mother-in-law and behind-the-scenes overseer of the household and finances, almost always knows the score. She comes to Griet's aid or not, based on what will best serve her daughter's interests and yet she comes across, not as scheming, but as practical. Comparable to Vermeer's intricate landscapes are Chevalier's long views of the Delft streets. She has a knack for picking the right detail to convey a mood, a cultural insight, a social contrast. Vermeer had the extraordinary capability to endow his figures and landscapes with a luminescence that gave his paintings lasting impact. Chevalier imbues this simple story with a similar light from within. For those who can set aside the desire to be entertained with broadly drawn action, there is glowing subtext and delicious tension throughout. Chevalier lets the characters be real--noble at times, disappointing at others--and though she doesn't tie up every loose end, she provides a resolution that is both satisfying and credible. My only complaint was that the ending came too soon as it tends to do with good fiction. In addition to a good story well told, Girl With Pearl Earring is a remarkable intertwining of the historical with the fanciful. Chevalier's tale is exquisitely believable and lives in the yearning face of this most appealing model. I will never again look at the painting without feeling the marvelous resonance and possibilty of Griet's story.