Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

This is a nice, thick liner that has so far held up against mildew forming. There are magnets at the bottom so if your tub is magnetic, the liner will stay in place. Although the magnets don't work on my tub, they add a little weight, which helps the liner stay in place. I prefer to use a liner and curtain because I don't like how shower doors keep the shower half closed all the time. Plus, cleaning the doors and tracks takes more effort than keeping a liner and curtain clean. This is one of the better shower liners I've used. I pair with a regular curtain that stays outside the tub, using these hooks: http://www.amazon.com/Maytex-Double-Shower-Brushed-Nickel/dp/B0042ZB1YI/ and I'm satisfied. Update: After three months of use and time in the washing machine, this liner has held up and resisted mildew formation.