Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I just ordered the All-Absorb pad, it's noticeably thicker than the Amazon Basic pad. If I didn't replace the Amazon pads regularly (like after 2-3 uses), it would start to leak onto the floor from saturation. The Amazon pads are a little less expensive (thinner, about 1" smaller in one dimension), so if you replace after every use or two go with that one. If you like the flexibility of a more absorbent pad or have a bigger puppy, this one seems better. Will try these out tomorrow. In the photo, All-Absorb on left, Amazon Basics on right.