Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I gave these eyeliners 4 stars as I have yet to test them. My review is based on first impressions currently. First off, I did receive all the colors pictured. I ordered the one being offered through Amazon with prime shipping since I knew if I didn't receive the colors pictured I could easily return it. But I did and have taken pictures so you can see the names and swatches. The description says 12 metallic eyeliners but only 5 of the 12 are metallic, which is fine with me. These have a slight sparkle on the outside where the color is indicated. The metallic shades are lavender, gold, green, green frost and sky teal. The other colors are all matte. Those colors are rosa, black, white, violet, royal blue, neon blue and light brown. For a price of less than 70¢ per eyeliner this is an excellent deal. They glide effortlessly on the skin and they are easy to blend as well. Plus the colors are also very pigmented. The only flaw I can see is that the liners are not smudge proof but then again what eyeliner truly is. I had it swatched on my hand for awhile and I rubbed it and they all smeared. But for the price, the range of colors given and the quality, I would definitely recommend this set to anyone. Hands down! I will try this out further and update later.