Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

It's a common mistake for newbies to lean into the Dungeon Master's Guide in an effort to learn the game. I think it's weird that Wizards decided to market this as "All you need to run a Dungeons & Dragons game", because the DM's Guide doesn't actually tell you how to play D&D. It contains none of the essential rules. If you're approaching D&D for the first time, you should buy The Player's Handbook. Every single player and DM needs to know about Ch. 7 Using Abilities, Ch. 8 Adventuring, Ch. 9 Combat and Ch. 10 Spellcasting - this is the heart of the game. Once you're comfortable with the basics, you need to start customizing your game with "house rules", optional rules that work well for your group and playstyle. Your game will naturally flow between epic storytelling and gritty tick-tock action. Your players will do inspiring things worthy of reward. You'll sometimes need to ignore the dice, or follow the "Rule of Fun". The Dungeon Master's guide has solid, time-tested advice on all of that and more. Unfortunately all the good stuff is crammed in to Part 3; the DM's guide hasn't changed that much since the original bound AD&D version, including the awkward arrangement of chapters and information. Ch. 3 "Creating Adventures" and Ch. 5 "Adventure Environments" are important reads, and Chapter 8. "Running The Game" is what you think you're getting when you buy this - practical, detailed advice on running a D&D game. I really like Chapter 6 "Between Adventures", which helps you fill in the gaps with careers, philandering, politics and real-estate. All of Part 1 may as well be supplemental. It helps as background material for the official adventure modules, and can help ground your homegrown campaign in some official lore, but it's by no means essential, and you could get bored and discouraged if you tried to learn D&D by slogging through the differences between Arcadia vs Archeron vs Avernus. Save it for later. Chapter 7: Treasure. Ah, treasure. This is the other reason to get this book: it's the best all-in-one official sourcebook for D&D treasure. The stuff of legends. Some of this stuff - Boots of Elvenkind, Bag of Holding, Belt of Giant Strength - has been in the game 30+ years. There's newer treasure as well, and it all feels appropriately quirky and powerful. Old-school DMs have a reputation of granting treasure sparingly, and Chapter 7 has suitably stingy (but useful) random treasure tables, and additional random tables to give each magic item special characteristics - who made it and why, how is it activated, does it have a name? I like to hand-write the magic item's name, characteristics, background and quirky details on a 3x5 index card and hand it to players when they identify it - it makes getting one a little more special. All in all, the Dungeon Master's Guide is an absolute classic, but not an essential classic. You could play for a year before needing to crack it open, and I recommend buying The Player's Handbook and Monster Manual first. But once you've gained some experience as a DM, it provides tons of useful knowledge.