404
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #52,257 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★★★★
Amazing, for the price.
This instrument is a real steal for the price. I received it at the promised time, which was great. Keep in mind to this review that I'm a beginning player, just with an ear and eye for detail. Now to the actual instrument:
Violin:
- Sounds alright, doesn't sound extremely bright or dark. Doesn't sound extremely shrill and piercing(in a bad way) like some student instruments I've heard.
-Pegs were not fit to the peg box, I had to push them in quite a bit just to get them to stay when I first tuned it. I didn't put rosin dust or peg drops on them.
-Scroll was sloppily carved, very messy and rough. Won't affect the sound quality, though.
-Pegs, fingerboard, and chinrest seem to be real ebony, I even filed an extremely tiny corner of both the the fingerboard and chinrest to confirm it(barely filed anything though, it's basically unnoticeable).
-Bridge seems slightly thicker than most I've seen.
-Looks great.
-The tailpiece allows use of ball or loop end strings.
-Soundpost isn't properly fitted, it's too long
Bows:
-They both worked fine, but were slightly different
Bow #1:
-Had a darker varnish than the other, which I liked
-Had a slightly sweeter tone than that other
-Heavier than the other
-Screw was easier to turn
-Slightly warped, but hardly noticeable
Bow #2:
-Had a more even, velvet tone than the other
-Completely straight
-Screw is a bit difficult to turn, but still able to the turned
-Ever so slightly lighter than the other
Rosin:
-Since I've heard and read many reviews saying that the rosin is terrible, I just bought Pirastro Goldflex and didn't use the one that came with the violin.
-Came cracked with the box dusty, much dustier than shown in the picture
Tuner:
-Haven't used it yet, I've been using my old universal tuner
-No don't do 420 blaze it, it's 440 tune it, you silly person
Shoulder rest:
-Extremely small and uncomfortable
-Cushion is so stiff, not even really a cushion
-Just get a better shoulder rest. A Wolf or Everest would be so much better to use than this thing.
Case:
-Will protect the instrument just fine, not sure if they always have the same color inside, but the one I received has such a pretty, dark teal.
Strings:
-Sound okay when open, but very muted when fingering. I replaced them with a set of D'addario Preludes, they sound so much fuller, warmer, and project better.
-Extra bridge might come in handy someday, as of now I just keep it in my case.
All in all, a great product, especially for the price. If you can't afford a better instrument, this is an amazing violin to get. It's really meeting my needs for my first violin. I haven't asked a professional or teacher about their thoughts yet, but it seems a lot better than some instruments I've seen my friends in orchestra playing on. I'm extremely satisfied with this purchase.
A few recommendations, only for comfort and instrument care:
-Get a better shoulder rest
-Put new strings on it, a cheap set of D'addario Prelude strings should do, Dominants would be even better if you have the budget. Infeld Reds sound great on it but the g sounds a bit unclear after a few months of use on them.
-Get an instrument cleaning cloth, you'll need to clean your instrument and strings of rosin dust after each play session to prevent it from sticking to the strings and varnish.
I highly recommend this to the beginner violinist on a budget. Great purchase, satisfied!
Edit: (7 months later)
I have tried this violin with several strings, qnd the E string seems to sound great no matter what. A tone qualities gold plated E strings seem to really suit it. It sounds fine with vibrato, but the G string sounds quite muffled in higher positions. I took the fine tuners off of the G,D, and A strings which made me really notice that the pegs arent properly fit to the pegbox. It's nothing too major though and can probably be fixed with peg compound, which I will be trying soon(I'll post my results when I try it). The D and A strings sound about average for a student violin in higher positions, nothing special. Still a great instrument for the price: perfectly responsive, decent tone except for the E string, because that string sounds very sweet, brilliant, and has the perfect amount of ring nearly no matter what. I am no longer using the bow that came with it, which did improve literally everything that involves the bow. The instrument seems to be warming up ever so slightly, which I am elated about.
Edit(11 months later)
-Peg Compound fixed most peg issues, I removed the fine tuners on g, d, and a and It takes me about 10-15 seconds to tune it when it isnt perfect.
- I've gotten a teacher, and she said that I have, "a really nice violin." She doesn't know I bought it from amazon, but she has heard it being played and has played it a bit and said that it sounds very good. It's still very responsive, and a better set of strings really brings out it's good qualities. I have a set of Infeld Reds on it right now, and the only bad thing is the lack of clarity on the g string. That may just be because of my strings being near due a change.
-I'm using a different bow and rosin, and the quality makes it much easier to play.
-in 3 months(It's currently the end of October 2016, my audition is in late January 2017) I'm going to audition for a performing arts high school and major in orchestra using this violin. Once that happens I'll post another edit if any of the feedback I get is relevant to the product.
November 2015 · Musical Instruments · verified purchase
the product in question
Mendini By Cecilio Violin - MV500+92D - Size 4/4 (Full Size), Black Solid Wood - Flamed, 1-Piece Violins w/Case, Tuner, Shoulder Rest, Bow, Rosin, Bridge & Strings - Adult, Kids
4.4★ · 1,843 ratings, as of 2023