Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

according to people

513
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #34,721 most helpful out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★★★★
Baby Bjorn travel crib versus Guava Family lotus crib
**UPDATED REVIEW** We've had the Baby Bjorn travel crib for two years now and I still love it and would recommend it to anyone in a heartbeat! For awhile, I used to baby it by putting it in a bigger suitcase when we flew. After a year of doing that, I finally got curious enough to see if it would hold up without having to be placed in a larger suitcase. It held up great the first time we did it (DTW to LAX). So as luck would have it, the third time we checked our beloved travel crib for a simple flight from DSM to LAX, it somehow got tagged incorrectly and wound up on a flight to China! I was pretty livid. So after a few days, our jet setting crib finally made it back to us. It reeked of smoke and probably air pollution but it was in one piece. No tears or worn down areas in the traveling case, the frame perfectly fine. I simply threw the carrying case and top/netting portion of the crib as well as the plastic case that envelopes the mattress padding into the washing machine then air dried it overnight. Everything else I wiped down with lysol wipes. Good as new. I'm very thankful that in this case, I definitely got what I paid for: a durable, well-made travel crib. The crib itself can still accommodate my petite three year old (35 inches tall). We still use it when we travel and we want to ensure that she has a safe, contained place to sleep. She did teach herself to climb out of the crib and can do so easily since the crib is so stable. Not that we condone or encourage it. I just thought it was noteworthy. **ORIGINAL REVIEW** I was torn between the Guava Family (GF) lotus crib and the Baby Bjorn (BB) travel crib. I decided to order both so that I could compare them side by side! Please bear with me as being succinct was never my forte. The carrying cases for both are stylish and subdued. For the BB crib, you can only carry it via two handles on top - much like a brief case. For the GF crib, you have two options: like a brief case or as a backpack. I like how the GF's carrying case gives you two options; however, the quality of the BB carrying case is better. The fabric is noticeably thicker and I suspect may be more durable in the long run if you're rough with your baby gear. The set up design of both cribs is instinctive. I was able to set both up without reading the owner's manual. For the GF crib, the mattress pad is secured via velcro tabs located underneath the pad. You pull the tabs through slots on the bottom of the crib and secure it to velcro tabs there. I was able to do all four velcro tabs just by touch. There's a bit of fumbling but I don't think that necessarily detracts from the ease of set up. I noticed that the mattress pad did pull up at four corners initially, but after a few days it now lays relatively flat. The BB mattress pad is secured via red tabs pulled through corner slots of the crib. They're anchored with a hook-loop mechanism instead of velcro. It was admittedly easier and faster to anchor the BB mattress than it was the GF mattress because I could see what I was doing. The BB mattress pad also initially pulled up at all four corners and is now settling down and laying flat. Neither crib had any discernible odor upon set up. As for the mattress pad, I'd say the BB mattress is double the thickness of the GF mattress. You can order a plush quilted sheet to make the GF mattress softer. I personally prefer the more plush mattress as my child is 15 months; however, I could also see why others would prefer the thinness of the GF mattress. I'd say it's akin to any typical Graco pack'n'play mattress. We have the American Baby Company 100% organic cotton interlock fitted pack'n'play sheet and it fit fine on both mattress pads. I feel that overall, the quality of material is noticeably different. The fabric at the top of the GF crib is not as smooth and luxe to the touch as the BB one is. One review noted that they felt like the former fabric could potentially snag more and I can see that happening. The top fabric parts of both cribs can be zippered off and washed. The mesh material of both feel exactly the same. To take down the GF crib, there are two handles on the top part of the frame that you simply squeeze. The location of the handles is indicated by white circles with upward arrows. For the BB crib, you tug the legs down and fold. Because the GF crib is shaped like a box, its footprint is larger than that of the BB crib. The legs of the GF also stick out further than the BB crib's legs. They're both roughly the same height. In terms of aesthetic appeal, I'd go with the BB crib. It's sleeker and I prefer the all black look versus the grey, white, and black of the GF crib. What I really enjoyed about the BB crib is how user friendly set up and take down is along with the materials used. I feel like the $60 or so difference in price tag of the BB crib is fair given its more apparent quality. Ultimately, I feel like you can't go wrong with either crib. They both have their pros and cons. If I could, I'd engineer a travel crib that had the sleek, luxe look and quality of the BB crib with the side zipper, carrying case, and folded dimensions of the GF crib. In the long run, I decided to go for the BB crib because I felt like it suited my family's needs more. Happy traveling!
June 2014 · Baby Products · verified purchase
the product in question
BabyBjörn Travel Crib Light - Black (040280US), One Size
4.7★ · 324 ratings, as of 2023
worser bester