Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I just got into detective style gaming at the start of the year and have been seeking a realistic experience. I've looked into all the subscription boxes like Hunt a Killer, but having seen videos, while they are made very well, they are more puzzle solving in the escape room sense than actually feeling like solving a crime. The Detective board game is a great game in itself but I found this one to be much more immersive and realistic. The quality of the components are the best I've seen and the presentation makes you feel like you've been handed an actual case file (minus the gore) from a police department. Newspaper articles feel like they are from a newspaper, photos are actual real photo quality, reports appear as if they could be legitimate documents. Everything you need to solve the case is included, which to me is better than having to spread it out over 5 to 6 months compared to subscription boxes which can add up in costs pretty quickly. I think the costs of these are a pretty good deal for the contents and the experience. It took me about a week to solve, sitting for a few hours each day to revisit things to see what I missed. Overall I think they did a great job with making it difficult in the sense that you feel like everyone could be the killer. The moment I discovered something felt great and made me want to dig in even more to keep that feeling going. I love that they have the sealed content with it so that just when you think you've seen everything, they give you a bit more. It makes it feel like your persistence has paid off. Ok, so now for the negatives. After combing through everything like a good detective, I discovered a number of typos and inconsistencies. While for the most part none of these are game breaking, one could throw off your logic and mislead you, however I still was able to solve the objective relating to it. The other downside is the amount of detective work that I put into it, such as creating a time table of every event that occurred, where people were, how much distance between locations, how far could someone travel on foot versus in a vehicle, analyzing every statement from suspect to witnesses for accuracy and such. I wanted it to be much more than it was and in the end a lot of that time was wasted effort as it was much more simplistic than I had thought. I enjoyed that type of work but I wish it had much more of a pay off. Overall I would definitely recommend it as it's the best I've experienced so far. I'm also open to suggestions from other shoppers of similar experiences. I hope these people continue making these cases and making improvements. I think some proof readers would help avoid the typos. I would love to have more in depth analysis of the cases, such as the efforts that I have mentioned, pay off. Maybe instead of the 3 objectives, have smaller clues to piece together that eventually lead to solving an objective. I'd also love to see these go more in line with some of the subscription boxes as far as including physical items involved in the case or perhaps just more emphasis on items in general even if in photographs, like the murder weapon, items found at the scene or elsewhere. Perhaps even an online component like in Detective where you can access the police database to corroborate suspect/witness statements like looking up phone records, vehicle registration, news articles, websites, etc. In general just more of everything. Even if these were deluxe cases at a premium I'd still purchase them just for the immersion. I'm not disappointed with my purchase at all and glad to have ordered the second one in advance based only on the quality of what the first had. I can't wait to see what they come up with next!