Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

The approach of this book is spot on. It is easy to read, brings in a good balance of historical references and contains some reasonable commentary (yes that means opinion). I found it very accessible and is a worthy read for anyone that wants to learn more about the BoR and their historical context. I see several “one star” reviews to this book that seem to imply that the book leans to the right. Several reviews center on what they believe to be a false interpretation of the second amendment and one review even calls it “originalist trash”. From someone who has studied the 2nd Amendment extensively, including a study of hundreds of years of Supreme Court rulings on the matter, I can tell you that Mr. Patrick’s commentary and “opinions” on the matter does in fact hold up against historical scrutiny. For me though, my one complaint is that he doesn’t write something for every amendment! This book contains no commentary for the 3rd, 6th, 7th or 10th which I find somewhat inexcusable. Yes, the 3rd may not be applicable today but the reasons for it further underscores the tyrannical experiences of early Americans and highlights the importantance of individual rights relative to the government. It’s still a worthwhile book to read and recommend but Mr. Stewart finish your homework!