Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

For some reason, black pen eyeliners seem to generally flow well, while brown doesn't. Black is too stark for my coloring, and I was completely disenchanted with multiple brands of brown that were dry, flaky, and/or like trying to apply with a fat crayon. (Sometimes when the same brand in black worked great.) Then I found the Revlon ColorStay Mahogany Flame. LOVE IT! Here's why: 1) It's not a pen, but it has the flow and precision of one. The tip of the brush is just right--the point allows you to make a barely visible thin line, but if you load the brush with product, you can get a nice bold effect. 2) The color is GORGEOUS. It's almost a copper color. Subtle but strong. 3) It lasts. I tend to have oily skin, so some eyeliners will pretty much just melt off shortly after application. When I come home from work 10 hours after I applied this eyeliner, it's still there. 4) Super affordable! This is SO inexpensive, and if you want to save even more, you can get it through Subscribe & Save. Cons: 1) If you get this in your eye, it stings. That's pretty typical of most cosmetics--they don't belong IN your eye. But when you're working this close to the eye, it's going to happen once in awhile. So just a word of caution. (If you found this review helpful, I'd really appreciate if you would click the "Helpful" button. Thanks so much for reading! Liz)