Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

**Updated - From 4 stars to 1 - Two hrs after putting this stuff on my eyes started to sting like I'd got acid in them - and I've never had a problem with eye makeup before - the Clinque eye makeup remover couldn't get it off and soap and water didn't do great either - I'm not putting this stuff back on again ever! It's going back and I'm not trying this brand again** ***************** Love the eye liners. I miss the smoothness of a liquid liner, but they go on very easily, they're just wider that I would have liked. Love the color of the brown one, it's a very dark brown, so really suits someone like me where black is a little too harsh, but still appears nearly as dark as the black. Haven't found the sharpener mentioned on the packaging yet, but someone said it was in the base of the liner, so I'll keep looking. The Mascaras are OK, not sadly as good as the one I was using that wasn't gluten free, but oh well. They don't seem to add much volume or lengthen, but on the other side of things, they don't clump. The shadows are OK, not great. Stunning colors and they look like the picture. The case is secure with a good magnet. The applicator is dreadful, but who uses the applicators that comes with these things anyway. They are relatively hard to apply though. Some of the colors are quite small so you can't get a whole makeup brush onto them without overlapping another color, which wouldn't be so bad if they were in order of darkness, but there's a light one intersperced with the darker ones... I found it quite difficult to actually get much of the shadow onto my eyes, especially for the paler ones. No idea how long they all last as I hate wearing makeup all day, so I tend to wash it off as soon as I can.