Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

Cancelled today because I was one of the unlucky ones to receive a box from 2016 for my March 2018 Allure Beuty Box. I was wondering why the products were SO "sad" as one reviewer stated. The mascara was clumpy, the perfume spilled everywhere once I figured out how to open it, and the lotion smelled "off" (I blamed it on the brand so I dumped it.) Overall, I feel duped.