Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

My cats are super picky and will only eat this brand of treats. I usually buy it for them from our local pet store, but I was lazy and bought it off Amazon. I think these are tainted or fake. My cats will not eat them, so I went to the pet store and got the same brand; my cats devour the treats from the pet store but won't touch these. I'm getting really sick of all the fake stuff on Amazon. It's really hard to trust what you're getting these days.