Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

Bait and switch. I bought this exact item for my dog a few years ago, time for a new one. The new one is a different animal altogether and much smaller, less fluffy. See photo for comparison. Other reviewers have had the same problem. Whether these are durable or not depends on the dog. You can see in the photo that our old duck is well chewed but basically intact. My dog is a strong chewer but she doesn't rip up stuffies. Other dogs are different. The original duck was definitely a favorite from Day 1. I'll have to see if there's another supplier to get a replacement from. FWIW, the recent unsatisfactory replacement was sold and fulfilled by amazon. Got a prompt refund but we want our duck!!!!