Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I purchased this online for the convenience and the price- I had wrist surgery and was not able to drive or lift. My Siamese absolutely LOVES this blue wilderness duck recipe when I buy it from PetSmart, she licks the plate clean. I received this delivery, everything about the packaging was the same, I even double checked the best by date on the bottom (August 10 2019). When I opened the can I noticed 2 things right away -The color and the smell. Maybe it is a bad batch not sure. The color of the food was almost a shade of grey and it had an almost rancid smell to it. I didn't have any of the store bought to compare it to at the time, so I thought maybe it was all in my head, and I also know from experience that there can be slight variation from batch to batch. I fed the food to my kitties. They were NOT a fan, and were hesitant to even touch the stuff, and for the 1st time since I have owned them they developed a bad case of diarrhea that lasted for several days. After eliminating this food from their diet the GI problem continued. We took her to the vet to rule out anything more severe (as she was still drinking, eating and playing with her sister). The vet was not able to determine a definitive cause, suggested she probably ate something that didn't agree with her and gave us a probiotic. She is finally feeling better. and I purchased new food from the store and she is gobbling it all up like normal. Will not risk purchasing this again. Convenience and cost savings are not worth a sick kitty.