Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I recently bought a couple of the BEST SELLER fragrances from Amazon and this particular one, at the time of I bought, has been one of the Best Sellers and also "Amazons Choice" and based on the favorable reviews, I assumed it must be very good. I presented this one along with one other perfume ordered from Amazon on her birthday and she tried them immediately and this one smelled BAD for both of us!!! It gave some Arabian Oils smell to us. The smell is very strong. The smell is just horrible to us. I dont know what could be wrong with it but I am telling my personal experience with this perfume. I bought BEST SELLERS trusting on Amazon but out of the 6 different best sellers, I tried two and one of them is wonderful but this one is horrible. I hate it. So sad.