Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

Most of the reviews were highly positive. I should have paid more attention to the negative ones. OK, I JUST received this yesterday and have used only once, but have been wiping smudges off my face all day - super embarrassing! I don't know what product the positive reviewers were using - the ones who said that this is waterproof, smudge-proof (even on oily skin!) and the best eye-liner ever! I guess I'm back to looking for a product I can recommend that positively! Very disappointed in this one!