Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

according to people

272
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #99,944 most helpful out of 571,544,897 reviews
★☆☆☆☆
What I discovered of "witches".
A long, long time ago, a committee was formed with three each of the species Vampires, Witches and Daemons. The only thing that was agreed upon was that the three species should never, under any circumstances, have anything to do with each other, ever again. This was working reasonably well until a self-depreciating, well educated witch with a great pedigree, a go-to pair of leggings and an insatiable thirst for tea meets a 1500 year old vampire with multiple degrees, an expensive wardrobe and a thirst for vintage wine. In summary, the first 72% of the book (percentage courtesy of Kindle) goes as follows: 1. Witch visits Oxford library to check out books on alchemy. A strange book pops up that gives her the tingles, and it takes several pages of back story before she decides to open it, and several more before she actually does. Deciding that it is an extraordinary book in many ways and very magical, the distinguished historian and avid researcher simply closes it up and sends it back to the stacks. 2. Lots of creatures become interested in her, including aforementioned vampire dude. 3. She rows a lot, jogs a bit, sleeps and eats a lot, and starts consorting with the vampire. 4. She consumes vast quantities of tea, toast and eggs, he nibbles nuts and berries and consumes vast amounts of wine, and we learn that he smells like cinnamon and cloves and likes Montblanc writing instruments. 5. Between alternating phases of weakness and stubbornness, sleeping and eating, some historical accounts of various events, and scientific discussions on genealogy, a classic Harlequin romance theme slowly unfurls, frustratingly rambling on for eons. The last quarter or so of the book gives the reader hope that the first three quarters was not endured in vain, but sadly, other than two quick bouts of action, and a lot of groaning and sighing due to unfulfilled passionate encounters, the book ends in a most unsatisfactory fashion, never even attempting to tie up loose ends, or apologize for wasting the reader's time. Unlikeable main characters, a meandering storyline and far too much descriptive prose focused on the mundane totally ruin what could and should have been a fast-moving, paranormal, historical romantic adventure. Amanda Richards, May 15, 2011.
May 2011 · Books · verified purchase
the product in question
A Discovery of Witches: A Novel (All Souls Series)
4.5★ · 47,090 ratings, as of 2023
worser bester