Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I gave up the expensive mascaras years ago for this -- it worked better and was way more affordable. Unfortunately, since last spring, I have been receiving an inferior product. At first I thought I had somehow opened an old tube that had gotten lost in my drawer. I used to get 2 tubes every two or three months, but I went to one tube a month on subscribe & save. I rotate my stock, but I figured somehow one of the tubes had gotten mixed up. I made excuses for about several months -- maybe I got it mixed up with an old one, etc. I ended up throwing out the ones I had and opening the new one as soon as it arrived. Same problem. I finally went to Walmart and bought a tube thinking I must have been getting old stock from Amazon. It was just as horrible. I have spent the last two months looking for a replacement mascara. I don't know what happened with this fabulous mascara, but I wasted over $60 on L'Oreal plus three other tubes of random mascara I tried before finally finding one that works better. Not as great as the old L'Oreal but better than anything else I've found. What a terrible disappointment. :(