Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

Initially purchased August 2016: Was 4 stars. Both my dogs like this treat. It's easy to tear off small pieces for training and the price is great. It reassures me that it's made in USA, grain free. It's not a low-calorie treat but by easily cutting it down to small pieces, it makes it a great deal and great size for my dogs. It's soft too so they don't have to take a lot of time to chew it and can get back to training. (For chewing treats for their teeth, I use Greenies, CET enzymatic toothpaste every 2-3 days and Nylabone treats.) They love it. As soon as I open the treat jar, they come rushing. I've used Ziwi Peak, Orijen bison treats, Zuke's Minis but these are convenient, healthy and affordable. Great value. UPDATE Oct 2016: Now 2 stars. My boyfriend bought another one after the one I bought in August was used up. This second batch is a lighter "fake" color (not brown but maybe tan), it doesn't look like it's jerky but more like cornstarch and flour-y: it's a grain-free jerky?!. I understand that there may be variations in the production process but this is way too different in consistency to be chalked up to that. It's like a different product. My dog doesn't like it and will ignore them, whereas the first batch, she loved every piece. It also smells different. While before it smelled like something humans could try, like real jerky, this smells rancid. Unfortunately, as a 'grocery product' it is not eligible for returns. I guess I'm now going to have to find another treat that is a good value. I might just end up buying treats at my local pet store again...more expensive but if it's not fresh, at least they accept returns.