Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

So last week I purchased this dress in green, extra large. It fit perfectly on me, I’m usually a large or extra large, 12-14 dress size. I liked the dress so much that I re-ordered it in black immediately. For whatever reason, the black dress fits like an XXL, and it is not very flattering at all. I included some pictures, not the most obvious difference but you can tell the black one has a lot more material. I noticed the size tag is not on the collar like it is on the green one, it’s on the bottom by the laundry tag. Also, the sleeves on the black dress are rolled and stitched, they aren’t stitched on the green ones. On further inspection I found that these dresses aren’t even made out of the same material! I’m disappointed to say the least. I really loved the green dress, wish they were more consistent. This is probably why there are so many conflicting reviews saying to size up, and others saying size down. I guess you just have to order two sizes at a time for each color and return the one that doesn’t fit 😑 I gave it two stars because the green one fit nice.