Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

according to people

149
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #210,525 most helpful out of 571,544,897 reviews
★☆☆☆☆
A total waste of time....
I picked up this book based on the reviews here on Amazon, and I wish I hadn't. To be honest, I'm surprised at the good reviews that this book has received. I'll admit, the first chapter of the book, I was prepared to be sucked in. But, the plot and details in the book were so poorly done, that the positive first impression I had quickly evaporated. The main character is laughably unrealistic, and it's obvious that the author was not in the military, and made no effort at research or proofreading (note to Lee Child: it's .22 "caliber", not "gauge"; corporals are ncos, and wouldn't do an officer's laundry; MPs are not "elite soldiers expected to take down green berets, etc"; MPs are analogous to "patrol cops" in the army. Reacher would more realistically be CID if he's investigating; etc.). Also, there's a point in the book where Reacher puts his pistol and ammunition in an oven to dry. I'm not going to even bother pointing out why this is a bad idea, especially considering Reacher's "military expertise". The plot is similarly full of holes, and the key point of suspense _still_ makes no sense (the "sunday deadline"). In short, rather than waste more time with this book pointing out everything the author got wrong, I'll just say to prospective readers that for "brain candy thrillers", there are so many examples out there that do a better job, why waste your time? Pick up a De Mille, a Cornwell, etc, or better yet, a Westlake, a n Ian Rankin, a Robert B. Parker ( for something more than brain candy)
February 2005 · Books
the product in question
Killing Floor (Jack Reacher, No. 1)
4.4★ · 65,167 ratings, as of 2023
worser bester