259
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #108,339 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★☆☆☆☆
Review & Comparison of 3 Brands, Tidy Cats, EZ, and All-Absorb
I am giving this product 1 star because of the price. In September, I paid $64 for 6 packages with 10 pads each. Now 6 packages with 10 pads each are $90 on Amazon. I called Amazon a month ago to see if this was an error in pricing, but they said that it wasn't. This meant that I needed to find another product, so I purchased Tidy Cats scented pads for about 1/3 less than the non scented pads. They were so strongly scented that I couldn't breathe, and the scent permeated all 2,600 square feet of our home. I could even smell them outside and in the garage. The cats would not use the litter box that I put a pad in. I sent them back, and got a refund, but still had the dilemma of overpriced litter pads. I purchased EZ litter pads from Amazon, and All-Absorb litter pads from Chewy, and still had left over Breeze pads. I have been alternating the three brands for the last 6 weeks. They all three work the same, same absorbency and same odor control. The All-Absorb pads are 1/2" shorter than the tray, but I just adjust it to be 1/4" on each end. The plastic edge takes care of the possibility of any leakage, but it's annoying that it doesn't fit perfectly. The EZ pads fit perfectly, and are every bit as good as the Breeze pads. Just to let you know, I have two one-year-old male kitties and two Breeze litter boxes. I change the pads twice a week because I am OCD. Once I forgot, and left them for a week. They were heavy and full, but there was no leakage. When I order again, I will, probably, go with the EZ pads because of the perfect fit and because the quality is equal. Here is the price break down, Tidy Cats, $1.50 each, EZ Cat Pads $.80 each, All-Absorb Litter Pads, $74 each. As you can see in the photo, the size of the diamonds is different, but they all are equal in thickness, they all absorb equally, and they all have good odor control. I was pleasantly surprised.
The products are, from top to bottom, All-Absorb, EZ, and Breeze.
April 2017 · Pet Supplies · verified purchase