Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I've used Blue/Buffalo/Wilderness for years, including these treats. I usually buy these at our local pet supply store directly. However, this was my first time ordering online and in bulk and something is wrong with these treats. ( I am a Amazon Prime member and have used Amazon for years.) They are made February 16, 2017 and expiration is 5/18/2018. My four cats usually enthusiastically devour these, but this time no one will eat the treats. They sniff it and walk away. This is alarming especially since I expect the same quality from this manufacturer. I opened one bag, and after no one would eat the treats, I opened another, and the same thing happened. I am trying to find a way to talk to someone either at Amazon that fulfilled this order, or with Blue Advantage/ Blue Buffalo directly. I would caution anyone considering purchasing these until something is resolved.I've included two photos from the back of both opened pouches.