Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

This is not an authentic Stila eyeliner! I’ve been using this brand, and this type of eyeliner for years now. This is the only time I’ve ever purchased it on amazon, and can’t believe they’re allowing this company to pose as an authentic cosmetic. This is so dangerous, seeing as the consumer has no idea what is actually in this product they are putting right next to their eyes! I thought at first it didn’t work as well as usual because I got brown, where I usually use black. (It was the only color left for their prime day deal- even more disappointing!) It smudged way too easily, and sometimes wouldn’t come out properly. Plus it would bleed, where usually Stila stays put even if my eyes water or I sweat. It wasn’t until I looked at the boxes next to each other of this one and the one I got from Ulta, that I realized the font of this one was slightly bolder, but was suuuper close. It’s a very believable knock off from the packaging at first sight. Don’t fall for this. It’s a waste of money, and God knows what you’re putting on your face. I’m so disappointed in Amazon for allowing this.