Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

At first I was going to give this a noncommittal "eh" and say it was average, but after using this for a bit, my opinion of it has actually decreased. The bad: it clumps my lashes together, giving me the exact opposite effect of adding volume; it makes my lashes appear even more sparse. One coat doesn't do much, but the more you add, the worse this clumping is. It's also extremely messy. It'll get on my eyelids no matter how careful I am. I'm also not really a fan of the brush. I've gotten used to it, but still not a fan. I'm not sure if the problem is the brush, or the product's formula. I'm going to wager it's both, because even with an eyelash comb, the clumping problem is apparent. The good: it doesn't smudge much. It's also easy to remove. It appears to add length, as well, to the eyelashes, but I'm not a good judge on that, as my lashes are already long. My problem is volume. Sadly, those good points aren't enough to save this mascara. It's not a product that works for me.