Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I purchased the same order last year 2015 and this new 2016 version is not what I expected. The ear warmer is thinner and smaller in comparison to the old one. I would rate the 2015 version a 5 star. The ear warmer kept my ears nice and warm at 20 degrees, Michigan weather. I have no doubt this would keep it warm below 0. I'm an avid cyclist/runner and I would have to take it off sometimes to cool my ears down. I will change the rating when they fix this latest issue. See images for comparison.