Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

You tell me- Should I try these? The box is water stained. The soaps lack consistency of form and look like they've done some traveling around a shower. One is half the size of the others. Bar soap can hold bacteria, BTW, so what does a sensible person do? It's hardly worth sending them back, but I'm fairly upset to recieve these in this condition. More photos when my phone cooperates.