223
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #136,784 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★☆☆☆
Terrible value. Confusing target market
It’s 2019, and discs are becoming less common. Convenience is everything, so you would expect a company like Microsoft to take full advantage of this and try a little experiment with an all-digital console. Behold, the Xbox One S All Digital Edition. The abbreviation ‘SAD’ sums up this product perfectly. Rather than charging a budget price for an Xbox One S that is devoid of a 4K optical drive, Microsoft somehow found a way to justify charging 50 dollars MORE than most base Xbox One S consoles for a console that is lacking features from previous models. Sure, it comes bundled in with a couple of games, but let’s be serious here: Sea Of Thieves is awful, everyone already owns Minecraft and Forza Horizon 3 is just plain old(it’s not even the current forza horizon game). The 1tb hard drive is one of my major complaints. For the uninformed, games these days are large, some exceeding 50-60 gigs. I’d conservatively say that you can safely fit around a dozen modern Xbox One games on this console, then you’re forced to invest in an external drive. This thing should have had at least 2tb in it, but 3tb would have been ideal. Microsoft has this program where you can supposedly ‘return’ your physical discs to a Microsoft store and receive a digital code for the game. How is this good? If you have more than 10-12 games on hand(which you probably do by now), you’re basically screwed unless you decide on getting a large external drive to fit the rest, not to mention you’re losing physical games that can be traded, sold or exchanged for digital merchandise that doesn’t carry the same flexibility. The target market for the Xbox One S all digital is confusing. If Microsoft was trying to make a genuine case for a console that the average joe would want to buy, this isn’t it. If you already own an Xbox, you have no point in buying this at all, especially if you don’t feel like having discs around as a paperweight in the instance where you decide to sell a current Xbox to get this one. Going all digital isn’t always a bad idea, but this tactic by Microsoft seems to miss the mark on form factor, storage space and price. What they ‘should’ have done was market a 150-200 dollar One S in a smaller package(since its without an optical drive), sell it with 3tb and include preloaded games that are actually decent. At this point, if you already own a bunch of Xbox games and 4K blu ray discs, this new console should be an easy pass. The whole thing really IS SAD, if you ask me.
May 2019 · Video Games