Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I tried these shoes on at DSW, then ordered from Amazon. They arrived and were super uncomfortable and stiff, so I went back to DSW. I ultimately ended up purchasing there and sizing up half a size, but I noticed some weird variability between the two shoes- the one on the left is from DSW and on the right is from Amazon. The shape of the top where it meets elastic is different- straight across on the DSW shoe, indented on the Amazon shoe. The elastic on the Amazon shoe is also bunched. The heel lining appears off center on the Amazon shoe. Basically, the shoes I ended up with from DSW are cute and comfy, but I’d recommend trying these on in person to make sure you know what you’re getting.