Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

according to people

173
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #199,342 most helpful out of 571,544,897 reviews
★☆☆☆☆
Ending full of holes
The ending of this book was so full of holes it was swiss cheese! 1. How could Amy get pregnant so fast with invitro insemination treatments especially at her age -- these treatments do not have such good outcomes as this; usually the first insemination does not work and sometime they never work (especially considering her age) - but, of course it works for her the very first time and on the first day of her return!!! 2. These invitro insemination treatments must have the consent of the husband and cost thousands of dollars AT THE TIME OF THE PROCEDURE, neither of which Amy had; 3. It would have been very easy for Desi's mother to have established Desi's whereabouts during all the time that Amy was missing and prove that Desi was not responsible for kidnapping her; 4. Why didn't the two thieves show up and disprove where Amy had been -- why didn't the landlady show and up disprove where Amy had been; 5. It was at 20 weeks that Amy told Nick that she was pregnant - that would have meant that she would have had to have gotten pregnant (through invitro treatment)IMMEDIATELY UPON HER RETURN in order to already know the sex of her baby, and for the invitro treatment to have worked THE FIRST TIME!!! Also, she would have been showing by that time and Nick would have known by looking at her that she was pregnant and she wouldn't have had to "pee on a stick" to prove it; 6. Also, since she was "being raped every day by Desi" while she was gone, wouldn't Nick want to prove that this baby was his before giving in to her demands?
September 2012 · Books
the product in question
Gone Girl
4.1★ · 161,269 ratings, as of 2023
worser bester