Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I will upload pictures of both the original first version commuter with the specs a little off and the one that I just got in the mail which is definitely a version 2 and the specs have been fixed! The pink and white commuter (in the pictures attached) is off a little because it's the first version of this case. The two pieces don't fit together as well and the headphone jack is not completely covered. I will give a warning about the pink case: it's a really bright, pretty neon pink but unfortunately it discolors and looks dirty. I will also upload pictures of this problem. You can see the inside of the case looks bright pink but the edges unfortunately turned darker. The black commuter (in the pictures attached) is a version two of this case and the specs are a little bit better. The two pieces fit together a little bit better. Also a huge improvement is that the headphone jack is completely covered. It's a little harder to see in the pictures since the case is black. I dropped the pink one before and it was fine and protected the phone. The black one ended up breaking (not from a fall) but because it got caught in my pocket and a little piece of the plastic part broke off. I had to order a new black one. I feel like this case could be hit or miss... It breaks by getting caught on clothing but not from a drop?! I think the updated version two of this case is probably better. I love the color options for this case and it's less bulky than the defender. I'd recommend going for the version two of this case for a slimmer yet protective case! Warning: case doesn't seem to have much front screen drop protection! UPDATE: Ordered another commuter in Aqua sky. LOVE the colors... But even the headphone jack is completely covered, the 2 pieces still don't even fit together! There are huge gaps in the case!! I thought otterbox had fixed this problem, but I guess not well enough. I compared it to my iPhone 4 otterbox commuter which fit flawlessly. I'm very disappointed. I really wanted this case to work. I will upload pictures of this problem.