Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I really wanted to like this. I took a chance on this brand when I ran out of Thayers Rose Petal Alcohol-Free Witch Hazel Toner because the packaging is so cute, but I'm switching back. The ingredient list is identical to Thayers, but this one a) is more expensive and b) burns my eyes in a way that Thayers doesn't. Even the rose scent is slightly different; this one smells less like rosewater and more like what you'd expect from a novelty rose-scented perfume for kids (cheaper, more artificial). Also: the opening of this bottle makes it difficult to control the amount you dispense. I always end up with a completely saturated cotton square. The Thayers bottle has a much narrower opening that's easier to use.