Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I just unwrapped the new rug and I'm very disappointed. Contrary to what others have received and reviewed, this rug is thin and of low density. The quality of the yarn is low and the workmanship isn't very good. I hope you can see in my photo that this rug is about 1/3 the density of the old rug (rolled up on the left), and the yarn is flat and lifeless. I purchased the old rug 3 years ago at a big orange box store for about this same price and this Safavieh rug doesn't come close in quality. Additionally, this rug is cream and beige (and the colors are okay) but I started picking up what I thought were loose black or navy pieces of yarn only to find they were woven into this cream colored rug. I am posting this review to give a differing opinion of all the 4 and 5 star reviews I saw on this rug. The quality of both material and workmanship is low. For a couple hundred bucks I didn't expect luxury but I expected an at least acceptable rug and not something that feels like walking on a beach towel. The photo shows the old similarly priced rug I'm replacing rolled up on the left and the new Safavieh cream/beige rug on the right. I'll look at different brands.