198
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #163,732 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★☆☆☆
not quite accurate .. hoping for 2nd edition
I was happy to see this book come out since I only had found the
older "Places Rated Almanac" up to this point. I am looking to
relocate and so this sort of information is very useful to me.
However, I am going to return this book since I am disappointed
with the rankings and question the accuracy of the information. I
know two towns rather well, and both were mis-characterized in
the rankings.
Example 1 - Macon, GA: "Snows occurs during most winters." This
is simply not true. There was a dusting of snow 2 years ago that
lasted maybe a day and a half. Previous snow, 10 years before
then. Long time locals tell me that it's extremely rare to get
any snow here.
Example 2 - Iowa City, IA: IC received a score of 7 for Arts &
Culture, Macon a 25 - this is totally ridiculous. There are a lot
of things going on in Iowa City, Macon doesn't even come
close. To award Macon a score nearly 4 times higher than Iowa
City boggles the mind.
I know these two places well, and for me the information about
these two places puts into question the rest of the information
in the book.
I hope there will be a revised, and more accurate second edition
out.
I give it two stars since the rankings/editorial comments are
important to me. While I can't comment on the
accuracy of the statistics, the rankings/editorials were one of
the main reasons for my getting this book. Raw statistics can
be used to look up specific information, but the other material
can guide your search.
April 2004 · Books