Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

The shelf arrived in reasonably good condition (a few little chips here and there, as expected for the price), and assembly was fine. There are 2 screws that jut out of the top shelf, so the top shelf isn't completely flat. With all of that, I would have given it 4 stars for the price, HOWEVER- After assembling it, I decided to give it a wipe (just using a paper towel that was slightly dampened with water, NOTHING else). Towel after towel came out BLACK. See photo of some of the towels. I don't think this is dirt, I think it's dye from the cabinet. Even now after all the cleaning, just rubbing my fingers on the cabinet I'm getting black all over my fingers. I don't have the time to take this apart and ship it back, but I am very disappointed.