Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

according to people

400
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #52,937 most helpful out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★★★★
Excellent BPA free plastic - Detailed Analysis
I had to do some digging to find out more about this plastic. The simple answer is that it's safe for virtually any use. It has a recycling code of 7, which tells us very little (only that it's not PET, HDPE, PVC, or any of the main 6 recycling codes). Corn and plant based bioplastics are safe, and those are code 7. Polycarbonate contains bisphenols (such as BPA) and is also a code 7. So, the code 7 doesn't tell us whether the plastic is safe or not. A note about BPA: it stands for Bisphenol A. There are a whole class of bisphenols (at least 16 different ones, including BPA, BPS, BPM, etc.). Although BPA is the most used and most often implicated as "bad" (endocrine disrupting), it is suspected that at least some of the other bisphenols have similar negative health properties. Just because a bottle is labeled "BPA free" doesn't tell us that it's safe. The manufacturer can simply use BPS instead of BPA, and call it BPA free. Still has bisphenols, still suspected of causing endocrine disruption, but technically it doesn't contain BPA. So I called VMI, the manufacturer. The container is made of Tritan, a copolymer developed by Eastman. This is the same plastic used in the new BPA free Nalgene bottles: NALGENE Tritan OTG BPA-Free Water Bottle 24 Oz. Tritan does not contain any bisphenol, so it is free of BPA, BPS, etc. It has good resistance to shatter, heat, cracking, scratching, leaching, etc. So this container should sustain drops well. It should be possible to clean thoroughly using heat and soap. It shouldn't respond negatively to chemicals of various types. It also appears to be a good oxygen barrier. It basically has very similar chemical properties to PET, from what I can see. This should make it good for reusable storage of water and probably even juice, beer, and wine. Although it holds 5 gallons, it shows up in a surprisingly small and light box. The fact that they can make this of state of the art plastic and ship it to you (given the size) for such a low cost is amazing. The ledges above and below the handle are actually more sloped than shown (they are not flat) so the liquid actually flows around the handle and does not settle on top, which can be important if you're storing wine or other liquids that may drop sediment. UPDATE: I ordered another bottle and this time received the design shown in the picture, with a blue handle that is separately molded in. This new design is made of #1 PET, which is fully safe plastic. So you may get Tritan or you may get PET, but either should be good, safe plastic.
January 2014 · Sports and Outdoors · verified purchase
the product in question
American Made Water Bottle, 5-Gallon, Blue
4.5★ · 1,058 ratings, as of 2023
worser bester