450
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #43,536 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★★★★
A Book as Good as his BBQ
If you're looking for that silver bullet that explains why your brisket isn't as good as Franklin's, you won't find it here. The truth is, there is no silver bullet. You want to believe that it's some magic ingredient, temperature, or other trivial element that makes his brisket so good and if you only knew that 1 secret, yours would be just as good. It's not that easy. It's a process. In all seriousness, he does let you in on the secret behind his great food, but it's not an easy shortcut. He had a passion, he tinkered, he produced some really bad BBQ but persevered, he paid attention to the details, tweaked some to experiment, found out what worked and what didn't and then, over time, became an expert with a well-developed sense of intuition. The truth is that formula has worked for hundreds of people, great writers, radio hosts, businessmen, programmers and other professionals uses that exact same set of steps to become masters, read their biographies and listen to their interviews, it's the same story. It's hard work, it's not because Aaron uses pickle juice blessed by a New Orleans witch doctor during an eclipse as an injection precisely 14.373581 hours before it goes on the grill. It's because he's got years of practice, years of paying attention to the details, learning what matters and what doesn't, and then persevering through the failures those experiments yielded.
You might think since I've given away the "secret" to Franklin's BBQ, there's no reason to buy the book, right? You're wrong. In this book he imparts his story, which is interesting, he gives you several clues on which things matter and which things don't so you can start your journey with more knowledge than he did. You won't buy this book and then suddenly be able to cook the best BBQ on the planet, but you'll have a deeper understanding of the craft and you'll know where you should experiment and where you should learn from his mistakes.
I found this book immensely valuable in my journey toward becoming an excellent pitmaster. I pre ordered the book and devoured it's info in just less than 48 hours after opening it. I did so because I ate at Franklins and it was the best BBQ I ever had, I made a bet that Franklin's book would be as excellent as his BBQ and I was right. There's a lot of great information here, but it's not like most BBQ books. It's much more about the process than the recipes (though it does have some). If you want a shortcut, look elsewhere but I think you'll ultimately be disappointed in the results. If you truly want to become a pitmaster and you're willing to put in some work, this is an excellent book to guide you in the right direction.
April 2015 · Books · verified purchase