Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

My 28 month old daughter wore these for the first time to go pumpkin picking. It had rained the previous day and she found a tiny puddle. She decided to go, "splish splash." No worries, right? After all, they are waterproof, right? Fyi- she was in the puddle for no more than 10 seconds. When we got home we discovered that her socks and feet were soaked, and her toes were wrinkled. To top it off it was a chilly Chicago Fall day. I was angry. For $65, they better to do what they claim to do. I will be returning. I will not risk a similar disappointment to occur during the snow months. I did like that they were easy for her to put on and take off. They are also very lightweight. But I am looking for a cold weather boot that is waterproof, snow and slush proof and this is neither.