Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

We use Angelsoft TP all the time, and I thought this batch seemed a little thinner, different. This morning it confirmed my thoughts when I saw a roll from the grocery store leftover, next to a roll from this batch in our bathroom. See picture - Amazon on the left, grocery store on the right. The Amazon roll is visibley darker, even kind of looks like its made from recycled paper instead..? Has a newspaper look to it. It's much stiffer, thinner than my grocery store roll. Again, this is the EXACT same package, roll count, everything as we buy from the grocery store. Very disappointed.